Hindsight cuts both ways in Clark’s UN campaign film
There's plenty to get frustrated about with Gaylene Preston's latest My Year With Helen, in which the Kiwi doco-maker spends time within Helen Clark's camp during her campaign for the United Nations' top job.
However, it's the boys-led system that will have you raging as the film plays out, not the way the film is constructed.
Tagging along with Clark, Preston had the idea to follow and see what doing good (as was Clark's desire) could actually achieve. But what, of course, transpired is that the former Labour leader and Prime Minister became the eye of the hurricane in a bid to become the next UN Secretary General.
Hindsight is both a blessing and a curse to this documentary.
It's a curse in that we all know the failed outcome of Clark's campaign, but it's also a blessing because what Preston actually captures, rather than an intimate diary of Clark's moods, dreams and desires is the fact the UN is in crisis. Having had eight men run it since its inception, what Preston's doco does is show what exactly is wrong with the global organisation, why the zeitgeist desire to get a woman to the top job galvanised so many, and ultimately, why the final result was a thumping defeat to those campaigning for glass-ceiling change.
Preston's smart enough to use the camera to capture the trappings of the UN, and while there are a few candid moments when Clark is less guarded (though these come primarily when she is relaxing at Waihi Beach, making meals for her dad - I defy anyone not to release a Helen's Chilli Con Carne after this - or a fleeting glance of her using social media in the back of the car on her way to yet another press-the-flesh meeting), there's little that's salacious or shocking on show.
"There's a terrible, nagging sense of the UN being desperately out of touch with the people it serves."
Throughout the entire film, whether it's scouting on a plane to Botswana, or attending meetings with the likes of Nancy Pelosi, Clark is the diplomat you'd expect at the UN and the restrained politician so familiar to so many.
While Clark's campaign becomes the film's raison d'etre, and Preston's camera wisely captures the voices around her, rather than seeing Clark grandstanding, the United Nations becomes more of a focus of the documentary as it goes on.
There's a terrible nagging sense of the UN being desperately out of touch with the people it serves, as seen in a subtle side shot of a US politician texting while an impassioned plea is made for those stuck in Syria.
If there's a criticism, it's that there's little debate and debrief into what went wrong after the final poll and the galling decision to install yet another white man in the top job; in the immediate aftermath, Preston captures the hubbub of others rather than using the exclusive access to get Clark's immediate reaction.
So it is that once she shows up she's already in composed mode, the perfect politician. But it's also when Preston reveals her masterstroke interview technique.
In just four words, a very laid-back intro of "what a thing, eh?" leading into the post-failed campaign interview, Preston says it all.
It's at this moment the candid camera captures the pragmatic resilience Clark is famed for, her never off-guard manner personified, but threatening to crumble. It's fascinating to see, and depressing for its implications.
However, in hanging on Helen for a little longer in this muted debrief, Preston draws us into her eyes, and the disappointment and dejectedness that lies within them. It's an utterly enthralling moment to behold and a technique that delivers an emotional and unexpected pay-off.
While My Year With Helen's focus is more on the UN bid (as would have been necessitated by events), and regardless of how you feel about Helen Clark herself (the brief insights probably won't change any deep-seated beliefs) what actually emerges is a definitive rallying cry for change within; not just for feminists but for all those frustrated with political back-and-forths in the 21st century
It's a sickeningly fascinating examination of the human condition, the politics of change and the lip service that goes in, but thanks to Gaylene Preston's light and deft touch, what it becomes, is a dignified and restrained, yet undeniable clarion call to arms.
My Year With Helen
Director: Gaylene Preston
Running time: 93 minutes
We value fearless, independent journalism. We hope you do too.
Newsroom has repeatedly broken big, important national news stories and established a platform for quality journalism on issues ranging from climate change, sexual harassment and bullying through to science, foreign affairs, women’s sports and politics.
But we need your support to continue, whether it is great, small, ongoing or a one-off donation. If you believe in high quality journalism being available for all please click to become a Newsroom supporter.