International

The tricky politics of natural disasters

George W. Bush never recovered from his flyover of Hurricane Katrina's devastation. Barack Obama got a bipartisan boost late in his re-election campaign for his handling of Superstorm Sandy.

Now, President Donald Trump confronts the political risks and potential gains that come with leading the federal government's response to a deadly and destructive natural disaster. Hurricane Harvey, the massive storm that has dumped torrents of rain across Texas — flooding Houston and other cities — is the first major natural disaster of Trump's presidency, and the yet-to-be-determined scope of the damage appears likely to require a years-long federal project.

Trump, who is suffering through a long stretch of low approval ratings, has been particularly eager to seize the moment. He will visit Texas Tuesday — and may return to the region again on Saturday. The White House announced the first visit even before Harvey made landfall. On Monday, Trump promised Texans will "have what you need" and that federal funding would come "fast".

"We will come out stronger and believe me, we will be bigger, better, stronger than ever before," Trump said Monday during a White House news conference.

The President's unconventional style has still oozed out. Trump has sent about two dozen tweets about the storm since Friday, marvelling at the size of the hurricane and cheering on emergency responders: "You are doing a great job — the world is watching!"

Indeed, he argued he specifically timed his controversial pardon of former Arizona Sheriff Joe Arpaio to capitalise on all the viewers tuned into storm coverage. The Friday night pardon wasn't an attempt to hide the news, he said: "I assumed the ratings would be higher."

Trump advisers are well-aware that the hurricane poses a significant test for the White House, which has largely been mired in crises of its own making during Trump's first seven months in office, including the President's widely-criticised response to white supremacist protests in Charlottesville, Virginia. Trump, who ran a real estate business and starred in a reality show before taking office, has no experience in the kinds of recovery efforts that will be required in Texas and has struggled at times to show competency in governing.

Administrations often tread carefully in planning visits to disaster-ravaged areas. Mobilising a president, his staff and his security is an enormous logistical undertaking and can pull local law enforcement resources away from the disaster recovery efforts. But Trump hasn't been cowed.

Aides said it was Trump who pushed for the White House to make his desire to travel to Texas known early. The exact location of his stops is unknown, though he's all but certain to avoid Houston, where flooding has wreaked havoc on the nation's fourth-largest city.

George W. Bush never recovered from his flyover of Hurricane Katrina's devastation. Photo: AP

The optics of a president's initial response to a natural disaster can be long-lasting. Bush was haunted by his now-infamous declaration that then-FEMA Director Michael Brown was doing "a heckuva job" — a statement that appeared wildly off-base after the full scope of the devastation became clear. Images of Bush peering down at the flooding in New Orleans from Air Force One also furthered the impression that he was detached from the horrific conditions on the ground.

"He understands why that picture became a metaphor," said Dana Perino, who was serving as deputy White House spokeswoman at the time.

Trump has played storm politics before. During his campaign, he rushed to Louisiana, in his signature "Make America Great Again" hat, to view damage from massive flooding. Trump made it to the battered neighbourhoods before Democratic rival Hillary Clinton, and while President Barack Obama was vacationing.

"We're glad you're not playing golf at Martha's Vineyard," one woman told him, a jab at Obama.

"Somebody is, somebody is that shouldn't be," Trump replied.

Over the weekend, Trump offered a sunny assessment of the response efforts while the rain was still pouring down on Houston and other Texas towns. He cited the "great coordination between agencies at all levels of government" and declared, "We have an all out effort going, and going well!".

Texas Governor Greg Abbott, a Republican, has so far praised the federal response to Hurricane Harvey, which has been blamed for at least three confirmed deaths. But with nearly two more feet of rain (60cm) expected, authorities worried whether the worst was yet to come.

On its own, a successful federal response to Hurricane Harvey is unlikely to reshape Trump's presidency. But with his approval rating perilously low, it could help Trump convince some Americans that he has the capability to lead the nation through difficult moments.

Trump's predecessors have also benefitted from the political opportunities that can arise after natural disasters.

When Superstorm Sandy barrelled across the East Coast days before the 2012 election, Obama paused his campaign to monitor the federal response from Washington. He travelled to hard-hit New Jersey, where Republican Governor Chris Christie, a strong supporter of the Obama's rival, lavished praise on the President.

Obama advisers said at the time that while they didn't believe the President's Sandy efforts were a deciding factor in the election, the praise he received from Republicans was helpful in the midst of a highly partisan campaign.

Newsroom is powered by the generosity of readers like you, who support our mission to produce fearless, independent and provocative journalism.

Become a Supporter

Comments

Newsroom does not allow comments directly on this website. We invite all readers who wish to discuss a story or leave a comment to visit us on Twitter or Facebook. We also welcome your news tips and feedback via email: contact@newsroom.co.nz. Thank you.

PARTNERS