Podcast: The Detail

School bells and whistles gone with international students

With the billions in foreign student money gone thanks to border restrictions, schools that took a nice chunk of that money must learn to re-cut their cloth. 

It's our fifth-biggest export earner, contributing more than $5 billion each year to the economy - but the impact of Covid-19 means the international student cash cow could be on its way to the abattoir.

So what are the consequences for secondary schools who make millions each year out of foreign students?

In today's episode of The Detail, Emile Donovan speaks to Macleans College principal Steve Hargreaves and Buller High School's Andrew Basher about the services many high schools are expected to offer, how they're funded, and whether in an age of post-Covid austerity, it's time to forget the frills and go back to basics.

Macleans College is a co-educational, decile nine secondary school in the Auckland suburb of Bucklands Beach with a roll of about 2500 students.

It's a high-achieving school - consistently among the top performing state secondary schools in Cambridge exam results.

It enjoys well-developed grounds, sophisticated IT systems, offers a range of sporting and subject options to students, and has comprehensive pastoral care systems.

Like all state schools in New Zealand, it receives funding from the Ministry of Education, which comes in three strands.

The biggest expenditure, teacher salaries, is largely handled by the ministry and Novopay. In 2018, this amounted to about $11m.

The second, property funding, is for modernising and upgrading school buildings, and varies year-to-year - in 2018, Macleans got just over $2m.

The third category is school operations - this is essentially discretionary money, which the school can spend how it likes: on scholarships, hiring extra teacher aides, buying sports equipment, and so on. In 2018, Macleans received $3.7m for operations.

But the school has an ace up its sleeve: international fee-paying students.

Macleans hosts around 300 foreign students, each paying $19,500 for the privilege - a total of about $5.5m - and that money goes straight into the discretionary spending coffers, effectively doubling the school's operating budget.

Macleans isn't alone - nationwide, secondary schools took in more than $170m from international students in 2018.

But with Covid-19 jeopardising the future of the international students market, that potential loss of income could mean serious scaling-back for Macleans, and other schools that find themselves in the same boat.

"We're in a bit of bother", says Macleans College principal, and president of the Auckland Secondary Schools Principals' Association, Steve Hargreaves.

"It's going to mean budget cuts. Staff layoffs. Pruning back what we can offer in terms of renewals of sporting equipment, IT equipment.

"We always contribute more to the maintenance of the school than what the government provides, so we're going to be deferring maintenance around the school."

Certain extra-curricular activities could be on borrowed time too.

"We offer everything, from robotics to underwater hockey.

"But also provision for students' wellbeing and the counselling we can provide. Schools now are feeding students, clothing students. There's a lot more expected of schools across the board."

Does the expected decline in international student fees pose an existential threat to secondary schools? Or will it spur a back-to-basics approach, forcing schools to cut out the frills and focus on a more straightforward, educational remit?

Listen to the full episode to find out.

Want more from The Detail? Find past episodes here.

Can you help our journalists uncover the facts?

Newsroom is committed to giving our journalists the time they need to uncover, investigate, and fact-check tough stories. Reader donations are critical to buying our team the time they need to produce high-quality independent journalism.

If you can help us, please donate today.


Newsroom does not allow comments directly on this website. We invite all readers who wish to discuss a story or leave a comment to visit us on Twitter or Facebook. We also welcome your news tips and feedback via email: contact@newsroom.co.nz. Thank you.

With thanks to our partners